Successful Defense of Various Clients in Extrapolated Overpayment Audit Appeals

We successfully defended a number of clients across industry sectors, including hospitals, physician practices, hospices, home health agencies and DMEPOS suppliers, in appealing audit results where statistical sampling was used to calculate to extrapolated overpayment demands. Through the Medicare claims appeal process, we have successfully argued that the statistical sampling methodology was invalid and should be set aside and have succeeded in obtaining favorable claims decisions on individual claims. Representative matters include:

  • We successfully defended a home health agency in appealing a $9.3 million extrapolated overpayment resulting from a ZPIC audit. Through the Medicare claims appeal process, we successfully argued that the statistical sampling methodology was invalid and should be set aside, resulting in the demand being reduced to under $175,000 before individual claims arguments were considered.
  • We are currently representing a home health agency in appealing an $18 million extrapolated overpayment demand resulting from a ZPIC audit. At the first appeal level, we were successful in reducing the overpayment demand to $8 million and are continuing to appeal the remaining claims denials.
  • We are currently representing a large, privately held hospice provider in the appeal of 12 ZPIC audits involving extrapolated overpayment demands totaling over $16 million. To date, we have been successful in overturning extrapolation in 7 of the audits at the first level of appeal and have reduced the error rate in all 12 audits, resulting in the overturning of over $9 million in overpayment demands.

You Also May Be Interested In:

  • Served as regulatory and deal counsel to BioPlus, a leading national specialty pharmacy, and ProHealth Pharmacy Solutions, a significant provider of infusion pharmacy management services in their sale to CarepathRx a platform company formed by Nautic Partners

    We served as regulatory and deal counsel to BioPlus, a leading national specialty pharmacy, and ProHealth Pharmacy Solutions, a significant...
    Client Type: Private Company
  • Representation of LogistiCare in its $80 million acquisition of National MedTrans, a single source Non-Emergency Medical Transportation (NEMT) benefit management company focused on delivering services to managed care organizations and governmental entities throughout the United States, as well as the extension of its revolving credit facilities from $200 million to $225 million

    We represented LogistiCare in its $80 million acquisition of National MedTrans, a single source Non-Emergency Medical Transportation (NEMT) benefit management...
    Client Type: Private Company
  • Representation of Spring Fertility, a leading provider of fertility care in Northern California backed by Wildcat Capital, in its acquisition of Genesis Fertility Centre, a Vancouver, British Columbia-based fertility clinic

    We represented Spring Fertility, a leading provider of fertility care in Northern California backed by Wildcat Capital, in its acquisition...
    Client Type: Private Company