Successful Appeal to Federal Circuit on Patentability

We represented nutritional supplement manufacturing company, Natural Alternatives International, Inc. (Nasdaq: NAII), in a Federal Circuit Court of Appeals case in which our client had brought claims against rival Creative Compounds LLC, accusing Creative Compounds of infringing six of its patents covering various forms of beta-alanine and its use as a muscle-building supplement.  The Southern District of California had dismissed the suit, finding the patent claims to be directed toward a product of nature (beta-alanine) and a law of nature (that taking beta-alanine in sufficient quantities builds muscle) and thus patent-ineligible.  On appeal, a split panel sided with our client, finding the district court applied too broadly the ineligibility doctrine of the “Alice/Mayo test” and that, although beta-alanine itself can occur as a natural substance, the claims containing beta-alanine as one aspect covered more than an unpatentable natural law.

Law360 provided analysis of the case in the articles:

You Also May Be Interested In:

  • We advise a multinational specialty manufacturing and technology company in all domestic and international privacy and data protection matters, including assistance in implementing a privacy compliance program and drafting license and services agreements, including data use and rights terms, and data access and deletion request response procedures.

    We advise a multinational specialty manufacturing and technology company in all domestic and international privacy and data protection matters, including...
    Client Type: Private Company
  • We advise a leading U.S. provider of senior care and assisted living communities with respect to state privacy law, PCI...
    Client Type: Public Company
  • We serve as lead outside counsel for a global Fortune 500 media company negotiating data protection and privacy agreements and contractual terms, including for engagements of ad tech, security infrastructure, financial services, and clinical healthcare service providers, as well as advising on U.S. and international security and privacy regulations and self-regulatory framework compliance.

    We serve as lead outside counsel for a global Fortune 500 media company negotiating data protection and privacy agreements and...
    Client Type: Public Company