Close X
Attorney Spotlight

Learn about Richard Arnholt's diverse government contracts practice and why he chose to pursue a career in the legal field. Read more>

Search

Close X

Experience

Search our Experience

Experience Spotlight

In June 2017, Pinnacle Financial Partners, Inc. (NASDAQ: PNFP) closed a $1.9 billion merger with BNC Bancorp (NASDAQ: BNCN) pursuant to which BNC merged with and into Pinnacle. With the completion of the transaction, Pinnacle becomes a Top 50 U.S. Bank. The merger will create a four state footprint concentrated in 12 of the largest urban markets in the Southeast. 

Bass, Berry & Sims has served Pinnacle as primary corporate and securities counsel for more than 15 years and served as counsel on the transaction. Our attorneys were involved in all aspects related to the agreement, including tax, employee benefits and litigation. 

Read more details about the transaction here.

Pinnacle Financial Partners logo

Close X

Thought Leadership

Enter your search terms in the relevant box(es) below to search for specific Thought Leadership.
To see a recent listing of Thought Leadership, click the blue Search button below.

Thought Leadership Spotlight

Regulation A+

It seems that lately there has been a noticeable uptick in Regulation A+ activity, including several recent Reg A+ securities offerings where the stock now successfully trades on national exchanges. In light of this activity, we have published a set of FAQs about Regulation A+ securities offerings to help companies better understand this "mini-IPO" offering process, as well as pros and cons compared to a traditional underwritten IPO.

Read now

Delaware Bankruptcy Court Vindicates AutoZone in Four-Year Litigation by Chapter 7 Trustee

June 22, 2011

Significant Win for Memphis Company as Federal Court Condemns Trustee’s Case Administration

Memphis, Tenn., (June 22, 2011) - On June 9, 2011, a Delaware bankruptcy court ruled in favor of Memphis-based AutoZone, rejecting approximately $7 million in claims asserted by Montague S. Claybrook, the Chapter 7 Trustee for the estates of American Remanufacturers, Inc. (ARI).

Montague S. Claybrook, as Chapter 7 Trustee of the estates of American Remanufacturers, Inc., et al. v. AutoZone Texas, L.P. et al. 07-51597 (PJW) was the lead case in a series of related adversary proceedings filed by the Trustee against ARI’s former customers. All of the other adversary proceedings were stayed pending disposition of the Trustee’s action against AutoZone.

The Trustee originally sought over $12 million from AutoZone for claims related to alleged accounts receivable remaining on the Debtors’ books after the automotive parts remanufacturing companies ceased operations in 2005.

After four years of litigation that included a $100,000 discovery sanction against the Trustee, and the Trustee's abandonment of some of his original claims, the United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware ruled that AutoZone was entitled to recoup approximately $9 million in credits owed to it by the Debtors. The ruling extinguishes the Trustee’s claims against AutoZone in their entirety.

"This case is a significant one because it moves the needle toward creditors' rights in bankruptcy disputes," said Kristen Wright, AutoZone's lead trial counsel and a member in the Memphis office of Bass, Berry & Sims. "Because it is a pronouncement of the Bankruptcy Court in Delaware, it has national implications."

In a two-day trial before Judge Peter J. Walsh, AutoZone established that account credits arose from certain deductions and allowances to which AutoZone was entitled under the parties’ vendor agreements, as well as credit for rejected product returns that, as AutoZone successfully claimed, ARI was obligated to accept both before and after the date the company converted from a Chapter 11 to a Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

Significantly for creditors, the Court found "no strict requirement that credits must 'match' accounts receivable for those credits to be recouped against the open accounts." Instead, said the Court, "the credits issued by the [Debtors] were an integral part of the parties' overall relationship and constituted a component of an integrated transaction between the parties."

Also significant, the Court permitted AutoZone to recoup its claimed credits collectively against the Debtors’ estates as a whole, even though the accounts receivable and credits claimed involved three debtor entities. Condemning the Trustee’s case administration, the Court stated that the "Trustee’s attempt to segregate the Debtors assets solely for purposes of setoff and recoupment in this accounts receivable case simply does not reflect the reality of his own case administration for the past five years." The Court ruled that, as a matter of equity, because the Trustee had administered the companies as a single entity, no artificial distinction between the three was justified.

AutoZone was represented at trial by Kristen C. Wright and Russell E. Stair of Bass, Berry & Sims PLC and Sommer L. Ross of Duane Morris LLP. The Plaintiff was represented at trial by Fox Rothschild LLP and Alan L. Frank Law Associates, P.C.

Click here to read the Judge's Order.


Related Professionals

Related Services

Notice

Visiting, or interacting with, this website does not constitute an attorney-client relationship. Although we are always interested in hearing from visitors to our website, we cannot accept representation on a new matter from either existing clients or new clients until we know that we do not have a conflict of interest that would prevent us from doing so. Therefore, please do not send us any information about any new matter that may involve a potential legal representation until we have confirmed that a conflict of interest does not exist and we have expressly agreed in writing to the representation. Until there is such an agreement, we will not be deemed to have given you any advice, any information you send may not be deemed privileged and confidential, and we may be able to represent adverse parties.